Puddle Flanges for Underground Pipes – GI vs MS Options, Pros & Cons

 

Explore the best puddle flange materials for underground pipework. Compare GI vs MS puddle flanges with a complete guide on pros, cons, pricing, and industrial suitability.udhhyog

---

Introduction: Why Puddle Flanges Matter in Underground Applications

Puddle flanges are critical components in underground piping systems, preventing water leakage where pipes pass through concrete walls, tanks, or foundations. These flanges create a watertight seal that protects both the structure and the pipe.

In India, the two most common material options are:

• GI (Galvanized Iron) Puddle Flanges
• MS (Mild Steel) Puddle Flanges

Let’s compare them based on performance, cost, corrosion resistance, and industrial use.

---

GI vs MS Puddle Flanges – Quick Comparison Table

Feature	GI (Galvanized Iron)	MS (Mild Steel)
Corrosion Resistance	High (zinc-coated)	Low (requires coating)
Durability Underground	Very Good	Moderate
Cost	Slightly higher	Lower
Maintenance	Low	Requires repainting/coating
Weight	Lighter	Heavier
Weldability	Moderate	Excellent
Typical Use	Plumbing, drainage, water tanks	Fire systems, low-cost concrete projects

---

What Are Puddle Flanges in Underground Pipe Systems?

Puddle flanges are circular discs welded or fixed around a pipe that passes through concrete. They:

• Create a physical barrier to water seepage.
• Are embedded during RCC casting in basements, tanks, manholes, or wet wells.
• Allow long-term protection of pipe joints in aggressive underground environments.

---

Detailed Overview: GI Puddle Flanges for Underground Pipes

✅ Advantages

• Hot-dip galvanized coating protects against soil moisture and rust.
• Ideal for potable water systems, STPs, and drain outlets.
• Minimal maintenance even in harsh environments.

❌ Disadvantages

• Difficult to re-weld without damaging zinc coating.
• Costlier than plain MS flanges.

Best for: Long-term installations in drainage pits, wet zones, or corrosive soils.

---

Detailed Overview: MS Puddle Flanges for Underground Pipes

✅ Advantages

• Low cost, widely available.
• Easy to weld, fabricate, and install.
• Suitable for low-risk areas with minimal water exposure.

❌ Disadvantages

• Vulnerable to corrosion if not painted or epoxy-coated.
• Requires periodic inspection and maintenance.

Best for: Short-term or budgeted infrastructure works like fire pipe sleeves or basic utility tunnels.

---

Which One to Choose? GI or MS?

✔ Choose GI Puddle Flanges if:

• You're working on sewage systems, water tanks, or high-moisture zones
• Long-term durability and corrosion protection is a priority
• You want low-maintenance solutions for buried structures

✔ Choose MS Puddle Flanges if:

• You're installing pipes in low-moisture areas or using extra coatings
• Budget is tight, and you're ready for periodic maintenance
• You need quick weldability on-site

---

Industrial Applications of Puddle Flanges

• STPs & ETPs (Treatment Plants)
• Fire Water Tanks
• Underground Drainage Chambers
• Hydraulic Systems
• High-rise Basement Utilities
• Metro and Tunnel Projects

---

Price Comparison – GI vs MS Puddle Flanges (India 2025)

Size (Inches)	GI Price (₹/pc)	MS Price (₹/pc)
2"	₹190 – ₹300	₹150 – ₹220
4"	₹300 – ₹550	₹220 – ₹400
6"	₹450 – ₹850	₹320 – ₹600
8"	₹650 – ₹1100	₹500 – ₹850
10"	₹950 – ₹1800	₹700 – ₹1500

Note: Prices vary with thickness (5mm–20mm), coating type, and quantity ordered.

---

Installation Tips for Underground Use

• Always use bituminous or epoxy coating on MS flanges underground.
• In corrosive soils, GI or SS flanges are recommended.
• Use anti-corrosive sealants or grouts to reinforce flange sealing during RCC casting.
• Do not weld GI flanges on-site; pre-fabricated welding is safer.

---

FAQs – GI vs MS Puddle Flanges for Underground Use

Q1. Which flange lasts longer underground – GI or MS?

GI puddle flanges last longer due to zinc coating that resists rust in wet or corrosive soil.

Q2. Can MS puddle flanges be used underground safely?

Yes, but they require proper coating (epoxy, paint, etc.) and regular inspection to prevent rust.

Q3. What size range is available in GI/MS puddle flanges?

Standard sizes from 2” to 24” are available, with custom sizes for industrial needs.

Q4. Is GI flange suitable for underground sewage pipes?

Yes, especially in STPs and ETPs, as they offer better resistance to wastewater chemicals.

Q5. Where can I buy GI or MS puddle flanges in bulk in India?

From direct manufacturers or stockists in cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Ahmedabad, and Hyderabad.